OR a forgivable offense?…
Urban Dictionary lists a deal breaker as these things:
1. An issue within a relationship that constitutes one partner breaking up with the other. Note that they do not need to be a “good” reason by society’s standards, but are specific and individual to each relationship.
I can’t believe he broke up with her because she didn’t put out after 10 dates. I guess to him, that was a “deal breaker”.
2. A deal breaker is ‘the catch’ that a particular individual cannot overlook and ultimately outweighs any redeeming quality the individual may possess.
The deal breaker was that he was married with kids and I don’t condone adultery.
Both of these definitions pretty much go with what I want to talk about today. For me, cheating is a deal breaker. It is that thing that I cannot overlook despite all other great things in a man.
Now, some may say this is unfair. In fact, many of my friends have said so. They say you shouldn’t look at something so black and white; you shouldn’t judge someone on the situation when you haven’t been through it with that specific person yet. Ummmm… okay, yeah I guess so.
To those rebuttals, I give this series of gems from the infamous book that 99.9% of men HATE: He’s Just Not That Into You
There’s never going to be a good excuse for cheating… This is a very complicated subject, I’ll admit. Some will argue, “It’s just sex, what does it matter?” Some will argue that you shouldn’t throw away a meaningful relationship just because of one indiscretion. This all may be true. But this is what I know: Whatever problems you may have been having in your relationship, they didn’t merit him having sex with someone else. Don’t ask what you did wrong. Don’t share the blame. And in case he tells you that it just “happened,” please remember, cheating doesn’t just “happen.” It’s not an accident as in, “Oops, I just slipped and fell into a sexual relationship with someone else.”… Cheating is bad…. If you are in a mutually established monogamous relationship, then when someone cheats on you, they have decided to blatantly disrespect a very important decision you two made together…. Let’s call cheating what it is: a complete betrayal of trust.
And that’s pretty much where I stand on it: a betrayal of trust. I do get that there are different types of cheating, even though I contend they can pretty much be put into 3 categories. 1). One sexual indiscretion. 2). Multiple sexual discretions (with the same person or different people) and 3). The dreaded emotional affair.

Please note that I placed these categories in a particular order. Mostly because while I think cheating is a deal breaker, I can see how some folks may be able to handle certain cheating… in that order… Once you get to the affair, however, I just don’t see how you trust that person again. And we all know how I feel about trust.
Really and truly, and maybe I’m just crazy (I’ve been called worse, it’s okay), but even the first one is hard for me to swallow, because even as a one-time event, it manages to place doubts in this man or woman that you didn’t doubt before. And I say that that is the start of the unraveling of your relationship.
Ask Usher… I know folks didn’t really take to Moving Mountains, but the song is sooo REAL!
“But the bad took away the good
She thinks that I’m full of it, arguments, always pissed, man I’m tired
Every kiss that I miss, girl you know I’m trying
You never believe when I say, and I never believe it when you say
I love you, and I shouldn’t complain about it
I should take it like a man and walk up out it
Cause we will never be the same, ooh
I’ve been standing in gas and you have been the flameI know sorries just wouldn’t do it
Her heart is obliterated, I’m trying to get through”
Ashanti takes it even further…
“Everything you did and everything you said,
now I’m standin’ here lookin’ like damn
I thought it was you and I,
now all I gotta say is why”
How do you move on from those feelings? How do you look at that person again in the same way that you once did? Sure you can try. In the Usher song, he talks about how she said they would see it through… but it just didn’t work. And sure, we all know many relatives who have endured cheating and made it to those milestone anniversaries… 25, 50, 60 years.
So I get it… I do. Some people can handle it. One of my aunt’s even told me that it should just be something that you expect at some point from your husband and/or long term boyfriend. Her exact words were something along the lines of, “hey, as long as your uncle knows not to bring anything back to this house… and he’s not crazy… I love him and I’m accustomed to a certain lifestyle.” WHAT?! This cant be what I’m supposed to be looking forward to, right?
Right?
I don’t know… you tell me. Am I being too harsh? Is cheating a deal breaker OR a forgivable offense?
*Note* Yes, I have been cheated on before, so I’m not just speaking hypothetically about these feelings.